MacDougall nine goals: Bournemouth 11-0 Margate and the FA Cup record that still holds (1971)
On 20 November 1971, in the FA Cup first round at Dean Court, Bournemouth and Boscombe Athletic beat Southern League Margate 11-0, and Ted MacDougall claimed nine of them, with Micky Cave and Mel Machin adding the other two. The MacDougall nine goals stand as the most any player has managed in a single FA Cup tie in the competition proper, and they remain a club and competition record. The nine were the work of a single-minded goalscorer, a future Manchester United signing filling his boots in front of 12,079.
This is how the rout happened, why Margate were the visitors with a grudge already settled once, and where the goals took MacDougall next.
Key Facts
- Date: Saturday 20 November 1971, FA Cup first round, at Dean Court, Bournemouth.
- Result: Bournemouth and Boscombe Athletic 11-0 Margate, with an attendance of 12,079.
- Ted MacDougall scored nine; Micky Cave and Mel Machin scored the other two.
- The haul is a club and cup record, the most by one player in a single FA Cup tie in the competition proper.
- Ten years earlier, at the same ground, Margate had knocked Bournemouth out, winning 3-0 there on 4 November 1961.
- Less than a year on, Manchester United paid £200,000 for MacDougall, a Third Division transfer record at the time.
Watch More Football History
The Football Documentary Channel
How Bournemouth put eleven past Margate
Bournemouth were a Third Division side on the rise under John Bond, and MacDougall was their marksman. Margate arrived as a Southern League club, and their manager Les Riggs had been asked in advance how he planned to handle the Bournemouth striker. His answer was flat: “We’ll treat him like any other player.” By full time that plan had produced Bournemouth and Boscombe Athletic 11-0 Margate, with MacDougall taking nine, Cave and Machin one apiece, and Margate goalkeeper Chic Brodie beaten past the point of counting. The crowd at Dean Court was 12,079.
The MacDougall nine goals that stayed a competition-proper record
The MacDougall nine goals have never been beaten in the FA Cup proper. The haul stands as a record nine-goal total, and no player has since scored more in a single first-round-or-later tie. Larger hauls do appear in the record books, but they belong to the qualifying and preliminary rounds rather than the competition proper: a ten-goal single-match figure is usually credited to South Shields’ Chris Marron in 1947, with Paul Jackson of Stocksbridge Park Steels matching it in 2002, both in early-round ties against amateur opposition. That distinction, between the proper and the qualifiers, is why MacDougall’s nine remains the headline number for the tournament that most fans mean when they say the FA Cup. It was scored against a non-League side, which does nothing to trouble the arithmetic.
It was also revenge, and precise revenge at that. A decade earlier, on 4 November 1961, Margate had come to the same Dean Court and beaten a Bournemouth team unbeaten at home and leading the Third Division, winning 3-0 through Johnny Roche, Alan Blackburn and John Fraser, with goalkeeper Brian Hughes saving a penalty at 2-0. Ten years on, at the same ground and the same stage of the same competition, the reply was 11-0. Both results sit in our On This Day archive of cup upsets and their sequels.
| Date | Result (home first) | Round |
|---|---|---|
| 4 Nov 1961 | Bournemouth 0-3 Margate | FA Cup first round |
| 20 Nov 1971 | Bournemouth 11-0 Margate | FA Cup first round |
From Dean Court hero to Old Trafford flop
The nine goals were the loudest note in a scoring run that made MacDougall the most wanted striker outside the top flight. In September 1972, less than a year after the Margate tie, Manchester United paid Bournemouth £200,000 for him, a Third Division transfer record at the time. The move did not take. At Old Trafford he managed only five league goals in 18 appearances before the manager who had signed him, Frank O’Farrell, was gone and Tommy Docherty had no use for him. MacDougall rebuilt at Norwich, where he topped the First Division scoring charts with 23 goals and won seven Scotland caps, and finished with 256 goals from 535 league appearances. The Margate haul stayed the line everyone remembered.
READ MORE: More single-minded goalscorers and the numbers they left behind →
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) About the MacDougall Nine Goals
What happened on 20 November 1971 when Bournemouth played Margate in the FA Cup?
Bournemouth and Boscombe Athletic beat Margate 11-0 in the FA Cup first round at Dean Court on 20 November 1971. Ted MacDougall scored nine of the goals, with Micky Cave and Mel Machin adding one each. The attendance was 12,079. Margate were a Southern League club and Bournemouth a Third Division side.
How many goals did Ted MacDougall score against Margate in 1971?
Ted MacDougall scored nine goals in Bournemouth’s 11-0 FA Cup win over Margate on 20 November 1971. It is the source of the MacDougall nine goals record. He took nine, with Micky Cave and Mel Machin scoring the other two. No player has since scored more in a single FA Cup tie in the competition proper.
What was the final score in Bournemouth versus Margate in the 1971 FA Cup first round?
The final score was Bournemouth and Boscombe Athletic 11-0 Margate. It was played at Dean Court, Bournemouth, in the first round of the FA Cup on 20 November 1971. MacDougall scored nine, Micky Cave and Mel Machin the others.
Is the MacDougall nine goals total an FA Cup record?
Yes, it is the record for the most goals by one player in a single FA Cup tie in the competition proper, still billed as a record haul in the competition. Larger single-match totals of ten are usually cited for the qualifying and preliminary rounds, credited to Chris Marron in 1947 and Paul Jackson in 2002, but those came before the first round proper. So MacDougall holds the record fans mean when they talk about the FA Cup itself.
Who else scored in Bournemouth’s 11-0 win over Margate?
Micky Cave and Mel Machin scored the two goals that MacDougall did not. MacDougall took the other nine in the 11-0 win on 20 November 1971. Machin later became a well-known manager, most notably at Manchester City. The tie was a first-round FA Cup match at Dean Court.
Where was the 1971 Bournemouth versus Margate FA Cup tie played, and how many watched?
The tie was played at Dean Court, Bournemouth’s ground, in front of an attendance of 12,079. It was a first-round FA Cup tie on 20 November 1971 and ended Bournemouth 11-0 Margate. Margate were the away side, a Southern League club at the time. Bournemouth were then in the Third Division.
Had Margate ever beaten Bournemouth in the FA Cup before the 1971 rout?
Yes, and at the same ground: on 4 November 1961 Margate won 3-0 at Dean Court in the FA Cup first round. Bournemouth were unbeaten at home and leading the Third Division before that defeat, with Johnny Roche opening and further goals from Alan Blackburn and John Fraser, plus Brian Hughes saving a penalty at 2-0. Ten years later the same fixture at the same stage produced the 11-0 reply. The two results book-end a decade of Bournemouth and Margate cup meetings.
How much did Manchester United pay Bournemouth for Ted MacDougall?
Manchester United paid Bournemouth £200,000 for Ted MacDougall in September 1972, a Third Division transfer record at the time. The transfer came less than a year after his nine goals against Margate. It was meant to solve Manchester United’s goal problem in the top flight.
How did Ted MacDougall get on at Manchester United after his Bournemouth goals?
MacDougall struggled at Manchester United, managing only five league goals in 18 appearances. The manager who signed him, Frank O’Farrell, soon left, and his successor Tommy Docherty moved MacDougall on. The move is now remembered as a flop rather than a reward for his Third Division scoring. It came within a year of his nine goals against Margate.
What did Ted MacDougall do after leaving Manchester United?
MacDougall rebuilt his career at Norwich, where he topped the First Division scoring charts with 23 goals and won seven Scotland caps. His career total came to 256 goals from 535 league appearances. He had a second spell at Bournemouth later in his career. The Margate nine remained the single match he was best known for.
Who managed Bournemouth and Margate for the 1971 FA Cup tie?
Bournemouth were managed by John Bond and Margate by Les Riggs for the first-round FA Cup tie on 20 November 1971. Before the match Riggs was asked how he would deal with MacDougall and said he would treat him like any other player. Bournemouth then won 11-0. Bond built an attacking Third Division side around MacDougall’s scoring.
Has anyone ever scored more than nine goals in a single FA Cup match?
Ten-goal single-match totals are usually cited for the FA Cup qualifying and preliminary rounds: South Shields’ Chris Marron in 1947, and, in 2002, Paul Jackson of Stocksbridge Park Steels. Those came in early-round ties against amateur clubs, before the competition proper begins. In the competition proper, MacDougall’s nine against Margate in 1971 is the most by one player. Those ten-goal totals came in the qualifying rounds rather than the competition proper, so treat the ten as a footnote rather than a rival headline.
Who was Ted MacDougall?
Ted MacDougall was a Scottish striker best known as a prolific goalscorer for Bournemouth in the early 1970s, where he scored nine in one FA Cup tie against Margate in 1971. He later played for Manchester United, West Ham and Norwich, and won seven Scotland caps. His career total came to 256 league goals. His nine-goal FA Cup haul is the achievement most often attached to his name.
The MacDougall nine goals, 55 years on
What keeps the afternoon alive is the gap between the two clubs and the size of the number: a Southern League side, a manager who promised no special treatment, and a striker who scored nine anyway before a record move to Manchester United that fell flat. If cup ties that turn into records and grudges settled a decade late are your thing, keep reading through our On This Day series.
Sources: Margate Football Club History, AFC Bournemouth, SaintsPlayers, LFChistory.
Watch More Football History
The Football Documentary Channel