Hand of Gaul: How Henry’s Handball Sent France Past Ireland (2009)
France 1-1 Republic of Ireland was the 2010 World Cup play-off second leg, played at the Stade de France on Wednesday 18 November 2009. France won 2-1 on aggregate. Robbie Keane levelled the tie on 33 minutes; then, in extra time, Thierry Henry handled the ball twice before squaring for William Gallas to score, the moment christened the Hand of Gaul. The double handball was plain; the referee, Martin Hansson of Sweden, did not see it. France reached South Africa; Ireland went home.
The tie was lost on the pitch, but the story runs on to what Henry said afterwards and the FIFA payment to Ireland that stayed hidden for six years.
Key Facts
- France 1-1 Republic of Ireland, 2010 World Cup qualifying play-off second leg, played at the Stade de France in Saint-Denis on Wednesday 18 November 2009.
- France came through the tie 2-1 on aggregate, having led 1-0 from the opening leg, scored by Nicolas Anelka at Croke Park in Dublin four days earlier.
- Robbie Keane scored for Ireland on 33 minutes to level the tie; William Gallas scored the winner in extra time.
- Thierry Henry handled the ball twice before squaring it for Gallas, the incident remembered as the Hand of Gaul.
- The referee was Martin Hansson of Sweden; the linesman did not flag and the referee’s sightline was blocked, so the goal stood.
- Six years later it emerged that FIFA had paid the Football Association of Ireland 5 million euros, described by FIFA as a loan toward the Aviva Stadium.
Watch More Football History
The Football Documentary Channel
How France 1-1 Ireland was decided
The tie before the Hand of Gaul
Ireland arrived in Paris a goal down. Anelka, his shot deflected off a defender, had won the opening leg 1-0 for France at Croke Park in Dublin, and the mood in Giovanni Trapattoni’s Ireland camp stayed positive despite it. The second leg needed only a single goal to draw Ireland level on aggregate, and it came early. Keane levelled the tie on 33 minutes in Paris, and Raymond Domenech’s France began to look ragged from there. Ireland led 1-0 on the night, the aggregate back to 1-1, and the tie was open again.
Ireland held the advantage through normal time. Their side was built around Shay Given, Richard Dunne, Damien Duff, Kevin Doyle and Keane, against a France that started Hugo Lloris, Gallas, Patrice Evra, Anelka and Henry. With the aggregate level at 1-1 and no away goal to separate the teams on the night, the second leg went to extra time, which, by their midfielder Alou Diarra’s own account, was exactly where France had hoped to grind toward a penalty shootout.
The handball, and the goal that followed
France won a free kick and sent it long. Florent Malouda floated the delivery into the danger area, the ball reaching Henry near the left of the six-yard box; Henry stuck out his left hand, stopped the ball, then gave it a second nudge before turning it back across the face of goal for Gallas to head in. He had handled the ball twice before the cross that Gallas diverted into the Irish net. Gallas scored in extra time, and the night was level at France 1-1 Ireland, France 2-1 ahead on aggregate.
Given saw it at once. The handball was so obvious that he was already preparing to take the free kick, and when he looked up Hansson was pointing to the halfway line to signal a goal; he ran after the referee while team-mates chased the linesman. There was a second grievance: replays showed Sebastien Squillaci offside and interfering with play when the free kick was taken. The linesman did not flag, Hansson could not see the handball from where he stood, and the goal was given. Ireland could not respond, and France had qualified for the World Cup.
| Minute | Scorer | Team | Running score (home first) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 33 | Robbie Keane | Republic of Ireland | France 0-1 Ireland |
| Extra time | William Gallas | France | France 1-1 Ireland |
The fallout, and FIFA’s 5 million euros
Henry’s admission and the calls for a replay
Henry admitted and apologised. He said after the match that he had not meant to cheat, and three days later issued a fuller statement, accepting that he had handled the ball, saying he felt sorry for the Irish, and suggesting that a replay would be the fairest outcome. FIFA never ordered one. Henry was referred to a FIFA disciplinary committee, which concluded it had no legal foundation to impose a suspension, so no sanction followed. Time magazine later listed Henry among its top sporting cheats.
READ MORE: More qualifying dramas and refereeing controversies in our On This Day series →
The payment that surfaced six years later
The deeper story stayed hidden until 2015. The Football Association of Ireland confirmed it had received 5 million euros from FIFA, which described the money, in a statement, as a loan to help with the construction of the Aviva Stadium. FIFA’s own wording was that in January 2010 it had entered into an agreement with the FAI to end any claims against it, granting a loan for a stadium in Ireland. The loan was to be repaid only if Ireland reached the 2014 World Cup; when they did not, FIFA wrote it off as of 31 December 2014.
The FAI told a blunter version. Chief executive John Delaney said the association had felt it had a legal case against FIFA over how the play-off had worked out because of the Henry handball. Sepp Blatter, then the FIFA president, had publicly joked that Ireland wanted to be a 33rd team at the World Cup. The payment only became public in June 2015, after Delaney mentioned it in a radio interview.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) About the Hand of Gaul
What was the score in France v Republic of Ireland on 18 November 2009?
The second leg finished France 1-1 Republic of Ireland at the Stade de France on 18 November 2009. France went through to the 2010 World Cup 2-1 on aggregate, having won the first leg 1-0. Robbie Keane scored for Ireland on 33 minutes and William Gallas scored for France in extra time.
What is the Hand of Gaul?
The Hand of Gaul is the nickname for Thierry Henry’s handball in France 1-1 Republic of Ireland on 18 November 2009. Henry handled the ball twice before crossing for William Gallas to score the goal that sent France to the World Cup. The name plays on Diego Maradona’s Hand of God, with Gaul standing in for France. In Ireland the moment is remembered as Le Hand of God.
Did Thierry Henry handle the ball once or twice against Ireland?
Henry handled the ball twice. He stuck out his hand to stop the ball going out of play, then handled it a second time to bring it back into his path, before poking it across goal for William Gallas to score.
Who scored the winning goal in France v Ireland in 2009?
William Gallas scored the goal that put France ahead in France 1-1 Republic of Ireland. It came in extra time, after Thierry Henry had controlled the ball with his hand and squared it across the six-yard box. The goal made the tie France 2-1 on aggregate and took France to the 2010 World Cup.
Who was the referee for France v Ireland on 18 November 2009?
The referee was Martin Hansson of Sweden. The linesman did not flag the handball and Hansson’s view of it was obscured, so the goal was allowed to stand. Irish players surrounded the officials in protest. No replay or reversal followed.
What happened in the first leg between Ireland and France?
France won the first leg 1-0 in Dublin on 14 November 2009. Nicolas Anelka scored, his shot deflected in off a defender, in a match played at Croke Park. The result gave France the advantage going into the second leg. Ireland needed to win by one clear goal, or more, in Paris to overturn it.
Where were the two legs of France v Ireland in November 2009 played?
The first leg was staged at Croke Park in Dublin and the second at the Stade de France in Saint-Denis, near Paris, as the away and home grounds of the two-legged tie. The tie was a home-and-away play-off, so each nation hosted one match. France, drawn to host the return, finished the tie in Paris.
Did Thierry Henry apologise for the handball?
Yes, Henry admitted and apologised. He apologised after the match and said he had not meant to cheat. Three days later he issued a statement in which he accepted he had handled the ball, said he felt sorry for the Irish, and suggested a replay would be the fairest solution. He also insisted he was not a cheat.
Was the France v Ireland match replayed after the handball?
No, the match was never replayed. Although Henry himself suggested a replay would be fairest, FIFA did not order one. Henry was referred to a FIFA disciplinary committee, which concluded it had no legal foundation to impose a suspension. France kept their place at the 2010 World Cup.
Did FIFA pay Ireland money over the Henry handball?
Yes, FIFA paid the Football Association of Ireland 5 million euros. The FAI confirmed the sum, and FIFA described it as a loan toward the Aviva Stadium. FIFA’s wording was that the January 2010 agreement was meant to end any claims against it. FIFA wrote off the loan as of 31 December 2014 after Ireland failed to reach the 2014 World Cup.
When did the FIFA payment to Ireland become public?
The payment became public in June 2015, about five and a half years after it was agreed. It emerged after FAI chief executive John Delaney mentioned the money in a radio interview. FIFA then confirmed the figure and described it as a loan for stadium construction. The FAI confirmed the 5 million euros the same week.
What did Sepp Blatter say about Ireland after the play-off?
Sepp Blatter, then the FIFA president, publicly joked that Ireland had asked to be included as a 33rd team at the World Cup. John Delaney cited Blatter’s conduct as part of why the FAI felt aggrieved. Ireland believed they had a legal case against FIFA over the handball. The dispute was settled through the payment rather than in court.
Who managed France and Ireland in the 2009 play-off?
France were managed by Raymond Domenech and the Republic of Ireland by Giovanni Trapattoni. Trapattoni’s Ireland had finished second in their qualifying group behind Italy, while Domenech’s France had come through the play-offs after finishing behind Serbia in their group. Both managers left their posts within a year of the 2010 World Cup. France’s tournament ended in a first-round exit and a players’ revolt.
What day of the week was France 1-1 Ireland in 2009?
The second leg was played on a Wednesday, 18 November 2009. The first leg had been played four days earlier, on Saturday 14 November, in Dublin. The two matches settled the last European place at the 2010 World Cup.
Why is the Hand of Gaul still remembered?
The Hand of Gaul is remembered because a clear handball by one of the game’s most admired forwards decided a World Cup place and went unpunished. Henry handled the ball twice before setting up William Gallas, and the officials missed it. The later revelation that FIFA paid the FAI 5 million euros kept the story alive for years after the final whistle. It is also often cited among the events that pushed FIFA toward video review.
The Hand of Gaul, in short
A double handball the referee never saw put France into a World Cup and left Ireland with a grievance that FIFA later settled in cash. You can trace more nights like it through our On This Day series.
Sources: ESPN, FourFourTwo, Goal.com, The Irish Post, The Irish Times, The Globe and Mail, France 24.
Watch More Football History
The Football Documentary Channel