Football League 100,000th Goal: The Milestone Nobody Can Claim (1929)
The Football League 100,000th goal was scored on Saturday 5 October 1929, and nobody knows who scored it. The record holds only that it was the 65th goal of that day’s fixtures. Goal times were not kept, so the milestone cannot be attached to a player, a match or even a division. Football usually knows exactly who holds a record, and argues about it for years; this one has a date and nothing else, a fact with no name on it.
What follows is what the record does say, why it says so little, and how two goals at either end of that count did eventually get names.
Key Facts
- The Football League’s 100,000th goal was scored on Saturday 5 October 1929. The date is the whole of the record.
- It was the 65th goal of that day’s fixtures, a figure compiled by the statisticians Tony Brown and Michael Joyce rather than by the League itself.
- No individual can be credited with it, because exact goal timings were not kept, and the same blank covers the 200,000th, 300,000th and 400,000th.
- The Football League kept no official register of goalscorers until 2003, when it realised the information had commercial value as intellectual property.
- 124 goals from the League’s early period carry no scorer at all, because scorers were not always written down.
- The first League goal of all was recovered in 2013: Kenny Davenport, for Bolton Wanderers, at 3.47pm on Saturday 8 September 1888.
- The 500,000th was scored by Gary Taylor-Fletcher on 79 minutes in Huddersfield Town 3-0 Rotherham United on 8 August 2006, watched by 10,161 people.
Watch More Football History
The Football Documentary Channel
How the League Lost Track of Its Own Counting
What the Football League 100,000th Goal Record Actually Says
The record says one line. Against the 100,000th goal stand a date and a position in that day’s order of scoring: number 65, on 5 October 1929. No club, no player, no minute, no division. Even the figures that survive were not the League’s own work but the product of two private statisticians, Tony Brown, later its official statistician, and Michael Joyce, whose database covers every player to have appeared in a League match.
The 65th goal arrived somewhere in a full Saturday programme. How far into it, the record does not say, because it does not say how many were scored that day. Somebody scored it. The people in that ground watched it go in and went home talking about something else. The Football League 100,000th goal was, to everyone present, an ordinary goal in an ordinary match, and it stayed ordinary because nothing in the record-keeping of 1929 was designed to notice it.
Nobody Was Counting Inside the Ground
The reason nobody can name the scorer of the 100,000th Football League goal is administrative rather than mysterious. An absence of exact goal timings makes it impossible to identify the individual scorers of the counting goals. Results were recorded. Scorers were often recorded. The minute a goal was scored, across a full afternoon of matches running in parallel, generally was not. Without minutes you cannot put the day’s goals in order, and without an order there is no 65th.
The deeper reason is that for most of its life the competition did not keep this information itself. The Football League held no official register of goalscorers until 2003, and it started one then only because it worked out the data could be worth something as intellectual property. Until then the job fell to private archivists working in their own time, Brown and Joyce among them.
The gaps are countable. 124 goals from the League’s early period have no scorer against them at all, because scorers were not always written down, and 9,226 own goals are acknowledged in League history, with the true number probably higher. A competition that has counted its goals to the nearest one still cannot name everyone who scored them.
Four Round Numbers, Four Blanks
Not one of the four counting goals between 100,000 and 400,000 has a name against it, and in each case the record stops at a date. The pattern only breaks in 2006, and it breaks because by then somebody was watching for it.
| Goal | Date | What the record holds |
|---|---|---|
| First | 8 September 1888 | Kenny Davenport, Bolton Wanderers, 3.47pm. Established in 2013, not in 1888 |
| 100,000th | 5 October 1929 | The 65th goal of the day. Scorer unknown |
| 200,000th | 8 February 1952 | The 49th goal of the day. Scorer unknown |
| 300,000th | 24 August 1968 | The 99th goal of the day. Scorer unknown |
| 400,000th | 29 August 1987 | The 30th goal of the day. Scorer unknown |
| 500,000th | 8 August 2006 | Gary Taylor-Fletcher, Huddersfield Town, 79 minutes |
The Goals That Did Get a Name
It Took 125 Years to Name the First One
For most of the twentieth century the first goal in League history was credited to Gershom Cox of Aston Villa, who put through his own net at Wolverhampton Wanderers on Saturday 8 September 1888. As late as 2006 that was still treated as virtually certain, the case resting on kick-off times: Wolves against Villa was thought to have started at about 3pm, Bolton Wanderers against Derby County at 3.45pm, Preston North End against Burnley at 3.50pm.
The reasoning was sound. The starting time was wrong. In 2013 an advertisement found in a newspaper library by the researcher Robert Boyling showed that the Wolves match had actually begun at 3.30pm, half an hour later than historians had assumed. Cox put the ball into his own net 31 minutes in, no earlier than one minute past four. Bolton had kicked off at 3.45pm and Kenny Davenport scored two minutes later. The first goal in league football anywhere had been scored at 3.47pm, and for 125 years it had been credited to the wrong man.
Bolton Wanderers now credit Davenport with the first goal in Football League history, scored with the match two minutes old, and record that 3.30pm Wolves kick-off alongside it. The work was done by the football historian Mark Metcalf and published in a book marking the League’s 125th anniversary. In November 2016 the club arranged a blue plaque in Bankfield Street, Bolton, near where Pike’s Lane once stood, and Davenport’s great-grandson came to the unveiling. Metcalf called it “definitely the most important goal in football”.
The detail that makes it football rather than archaeology is that Davenport’s team lost. Derby County beat Bolton Wanderers 6-3, with Davenport scoring the first two of Bolton’s three.
Number 500,000 Had a Name the Same Night
By the summer of 2006 the League had learned the lesson. It knew the running total had reached 499,855 goals across 171,599 fixtures by the close of 2005-06, it knew roughly which evening the 500,000th would land on, and it had commissioned a trophy in advance for whoever scored it. John Nagle, then its head of communications, framed the number in matches rather than goals: upwards of 170,000 of them, across 107 full seasons, with two world wars costing the competition eleven years.
It arrived on Tuesday 8 August 2006 at Huddersfield Town, where the home side beat Rotherham United 3-0 in League One. Luke Beckett scored a penalty on 36 minutes, Pawel Abbott made it 2-0 on 45, and on 79 minutes Gary Taylor-Fletcher hit a 25-yard drive into the top-left corner for English league football’s 500,000th goal. The attendance was 10,161, the referee was J P Robinson of East Yorkshire, and for once the paperwork was ready before the ball crossed the line.
Why 1888 Could Be Solved and 1929 Cannot
The difference is what got printed. Boyling could crack 1888 because kick-off times were advertised in newspapers, and because a five-match programme with known starting times is a small enough problem to solve on paper. 5 October 1929 is a different shape entirely: a full Football League programme across four divisions, with the goals recorded but their minutes mostly not. To find the 65th you would need a running clock for every match at once.
That is not the same as impossible forever: nothing about the Davenport case was, until somebody read an advertisement. But the honest position for 1929 remains a date, an ordinal and no name.
READ MORE: More forgotten corners of the record books, in our On This Day series →
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) About the Football League’s 100,000th Goal
When was the Football League’s 100,000th goal scored?
On Saturday 5 October 1929. The surviving record places it 65th in that day’s order of scoring and gives no further detail. That single line is the entire surviving record of the milestone. The date is certain; everything after the date is not.
Who scored the Football League’s 100,000th goal?
Nobody knows, and on the current record nobody can know. No individual can be credited, because the times of goals were not recorded in 1929. Without minutes there is no way to order the day’s goals and identify the 65th. Somebody scored it and the fact was never written down in a form that survives.
Why can’t the scorer of the 100,000th League goal be identified?
Because the times of goals were not systematically recorded across a full Saturday programme. Results and scorers were often noted, but the minute each goal was scored generally was not, and dozens of matches were being played simultaneously. An absence of exact goal timings makes individual identification impossible. It is a gap in the paperwork rather than a dispute between sources.
Did the Football League keep records of its own goalscorers in 1929?
No. The League held no official register of goalscorers until 2003, and only started one then because it realised the information had commercial value as intellectual property. Before that the work was done by private archivists in their own time. Two of them, Tony Brown and Michael Joyce, compiled the milestone dates.
Are the scorers of the League’s 200,000th, 300,000th and 400,000th goals known?
No, and for the same reason. The 200,000th was 49th in the order of play on 8 February 1952, the 300,000th 99th on 24 August 1968, and the 400,000th 30th on 29 August 1987. In each case the date and the position within the day survive, but the scorer does not. All four counting goals from 1929 to 1987 are anonymous.
Who scored English league football’s 500,000th goal?
Gary Taylor-Fletcher of Huddersfield Town, on 79 minutes against Rotherham United on 8 August 2006. It was a 25-yard drive into the top-left corner in a League One fixture that Huddersfield won 3-0, English league football’s 500,000th goal. The Football League had commissioned a trophy for the scorer before the evening began.
Who scored the first goal in Football League history?
Kenny Davenport of Bolton Wanderers, at 3.47pm on Saturday 8 September 1888, against Derby County. It was credited to him only in 2013, after research published to mark the League’s 125th anniversary. Before that it had been widely attributed to Gershom Cox of Aston Villa, who scored an own goal at Wolverhampton Wanderers the same afternoon.
How was the scorer of the first League goal finally established?
Through a kick-off time found in a newspaper advertisement. In 2013 Robert Boyling, working in a newspaper library, established that the Wolverhampton Wanderers against Aston Villa match had started at 3.30pm rather than the 3pm historians had assumed. Cox’s own goal came 31 minutes in, so no earlier than 4.01pm, while Bolton had started at 3.45pm and Davenport scored inside two minutes. The football historian Mark Metcalf published the finding.
Are there other Football League goals with no known scorer?
Yes, 124 of them. 124 goals from the League’s early period have no scorer against them, because scorers were not always written down at the time. There are also 9,226 acknowledged own goals in League history, with the true number probably higher.
Could the scorer of the 100,000th League goal ever be identified?
It would need a source of goal minutes that nobody has yet assembled for 5 October 1929. The 1888 case shows that these questions can be reopened, since it was settled 125 years later by one advertisement in a newspaper library. But that involved five matches, while 1929 involved a full programme across four divisions. Nobody has published a solution, and until somebody does, the honest answer is that the goal has a date and no name.
How many goals had been scored in English league football by 2006?
499,855 by the close of 2005-06, across 171,599 fixtures, a total that includes the Premier League from 1992 onwards. John Nagle of the Football League described the half-million as the product of 107 full seasons and upwards of 170,000 matches, with two world wars costing the competition eleven years.
The Football League’s 100,000th Goal, Still Unclaimed
Almost a century on, the entry has not changed: 5 October 1929, the 65th goal of the day, scorer unknown. A record book exists to answer exactly this kind of question, and on this one it does not, while the 1888 case shows that such blanks need not be permanent. Somewhere in a newspaper library there may still be a column of goal times nobody has read since the week they were printed. More anniversaries that turn out to be stranger than their reputation are in our On This Day archive.
Sources: The Independent, BBC Sport, Reuters, Bolton News, Bolton Wanderers.
Watch More Football History
The Football Documentary Channel